Published on , commented on July 19, 2022
Is OpenFlow the Best Tool for Overlay Virtual Networks?
Overlay virtual networks were the first commercial-grade OpenFlow use case – Nicira’s Network Virtualization Platform (NVP – rebranded as VMware NSX for Multiple Hypervisors after the acquisition, and finally rearchitected into VMware NSX-T) used OpenFlow to program the hypervisor virtual switches (Open vSwitches – OVS).
OpenStack is using the same approach in its OVS Neutron plugin, and it seems Open Daylight aims to reinvent that same wheel, replacing OVS plugin running on the hypervisor host agent with central controller.
Does that mean one should always use OpenFlow to implement overlay virtual networks? Not really, OpenFlow is not exactly the best tool for the job.
Will Network Engineers Become Programmers?
I know numerous engineers who decided to pursue a career in networking because they didn’t want to deep-dive into programming. Will that change when the Software Defined Everything takes over the world?
TL&DR summary: Of course not.
Can We Just Throw More Bandwidth at a Problem?
One of my readers sent me an interesting question:
I have been reading at many places about "throwing more bandwidth at the problem." How far is this statement valid? Should the applications(servers) work with the assumption that there is infinite bandwidth provided at the fabric level?
Moore’s law works in our favor. It’s already cheaper (in some environments) to add bandwidth than to deploy QoS.
30 Years of Yammering
Some of the comments I get every time I write about the idea of merging network services deployment with application deployments, and making application developers responsible for the results of their code (aka DevOps) remind me of a very long list of “this will never work” sentiments I encountered in the 30 years I spent in IT and networking. Here are just a few of them:
Virtual Networking Implementation Taxonomy
I’m not sure I wrote about the taxonomy of numerous virtual networking implementations. Just in case, here it is ;)
Layer-2 or layer-3 networks?
Some virtual networking solutions emulate thick coax cable (more precisely, layer-2 switch), giving their users the impression of having regular VLAN-like layer-2 segments.
FCoE and Nexus 1000v QoS
One of my readers wanted to deploy FCoE on UCS in combination with Nexus 1000v and wondered how the FCoE traffic impacts QoS on Nexus 1000v. He wrote:
Let's say I want 4Gb for FCoE. Should I add bandwidth shares up to 60% in the nexus 1000v CBWFQ config so that 40% are in the default-class as 1kv is not aware of FCoE traffic? Or add up to 100% with the assumption that the 1kv knows there is only 6Gb left for network? Also, will the Nexus 1000v be able to detect contention on the uplink even if it doesn't see the FCoE traffic?
As always, things aren’t as simple as they look.
Building Scalable Web Applications – Final Presentations
Last Friday my students attending this year’s Designing Scalable Web Applications course presented their semester-long assignments. I can’t tell you how pleasantly surprised I was – the results were much better and more polished than what I’ve seen during the previous years.
What Are Linux Containers?
Everyone talks about Linux containers these days like they would be the hottest thing invented this spring. In reality, it’s a pretty old technology that was heavily used by some smart web hosting companies for years (but of course, some people think mentioning Google makes everything look sexier).
If you’re interested in a high-level overview of differences between Linux containers and more traditional virtual machines, watch the video from the Introduction to Virtual Networking webinar.
It’s OK to Let Developers Go @ Amazon Web Services, but Not at Home? You Must Be Kidding!
Recently I was discussing the benefits and drawbacks of virtual appliances, software-defined data centers, and self-service approach to application deployment with a group of extremely smart networking engineers.
After the usual set of objections, someone said “but if we won’t become more flexible, the developers will simply go to Amazon. In fact, they already use Amazon Web Services.”
… updated on Monday, February 15, 2021 15:00 UTC
How Line-rate Is Line-rate?
During yesterday’s Data Center Fabrics Update presentation, one of the attendees sent me this question while I was talking about the Arista 7300 series switches:
Is the 7300 really non-blocking at all packet sizes? With only 2 x Trident-2 per line card it can't support non-blocking for small packets based on Trident-2 architecture.
It was an obvious example of vendor bickering, so I ignored the question during the presentation, but it still intrigued me, so I decided to do some more research.
Queuing Mechanisms in Modern Switches
A long while ago there was an interesting discussion started by Brad Hedlund (then at Dell Force10) comparing leaf-and-spine (Clos) fabrics built from fixed-configuration pizza box switches with high-end chassis switches. The comments made by other readers were all over the place (addressing pricing, wiring, power consumption) but surprisingly nobody addressed the queuing issues.
This blog post focuses on queuing mechanisms available within a switch; the next one will address end-to-end queuing issues in leaf-and-spine fabrics.
The best spam comment (so far)
Idiots posting random comments with (not-so-very) hidden links to whatever warez they're selling are utterly annoying, but there's always one-in-a-million chance for a hilarious one. This is what I got on the Traffic Trombone post:
The traffic across the network core and the end-to-end latency would be minimal (the same packet would traverse the core only once), increasing visits to my adult site.
Data Center Protocols in HP Switches
HP representatives made some pretty bold claims during Networking Tech Field Day 1, including “our switches will support EVB, FCoE, SPB and TRILL.” I took them three years to deliver on those promises (and the hardware they had at that time doesn’t exactly support all features they promised), but their current protocol coverage is impressive.
Benefits of SDN (or: SDN is like IPv6)
A while ago Paul Stewart wrote a fantastic blog post listing the potential business benefits of SDN (as promoted by SDN evangelists and SDN-washing vendors).
Here’s his list:
How Do I Start My First Overlay Virtual Networking Project?
After the Designing Private Cloud Infrastructure workshop I had in Slovenia last week (in a packed room of ~60 people), someone approached me with a simple question: “I like the idea of using overlay virtual networks in my private cloud, but where do I start?”