When You Find Yourself on Mount Stupid
The early October 2021 Facebook outage generated a predictable phenomenon – couch epidemiologists became experts in little-known Bridging the Gap Protocol (BGP), including its Introvert and Extrovert variants. Unfortunately, I also witnessed several unexpected trips to Mount Stupid by people who should have known better.
To set the record straight: everyone’s been there, and the more vocal you tend to be on social media (including mailing lists), the more probable it is that you’ll take a wrong turn and end there. What matters is how gracefully you descend and what you’ve learned on the way back.
Appreciating the Networking Fundamentals
When I started creating the How Networks Really Work series, I wondered whether our subscribers (mostly seasoned networking engineers) would find it useful. Turns out at least some of them do; this is what a long-time subscriber sent me:
How Networks Really Work is great, it’s like looking from a plane and seeing how all the roads are connected to each other. I know networking just enough to design and manage a corporate network, but there are many things I have learned, used and forgotten along the way.
On the Usability of OSI Layered Networking Model
Two weeks ago I replied to a battle-scar reaction to 7-layer OSI model, this time I’ll address a much more nuanced view from Russ White. Please read his article first (as always, it’s well worth reading) and when you come back we’ll focus on this claim:
The OSI Model does not accurately describe networks.
Like with any tool in your toolbox, you can view the 7-layer OSI model in a number of ways. In the case of OSI model, it can be used:
Grasp the Fundamentals before Spreading Opinions
I should have known better, but I got pulled into another stretched VLANs for disaster recovery tweetfest. Surprisingly, most of the tweets were along the lines of you really shouldn’t be doing that and that would never work well, but then I guess I was only exposed to a small curated bubble of common sense… until this gem appeared in my timeline:

Interestingly, that’s exactly how IP works:
Learning Networking Fundamentals at University?
One of my readers sent me this interesting question:
It begs the question in how far graduated students with a degree in computer science or applied IT infrastructure courses (on university or college level or equivalent) are actually aware of networking fundamentals. I work for a vendor independent networking firm and a lot of my new colleagues are college graduates. Positively, they are very well versed in automation, scripting and other programming skills, but I never asked them what actually happens when a packet traverses a network. I wonder what the result would be…
I can tell you what the result would be in my days: blank stares and confusion. I “enjoyed” a half-year course in computer networking that focused exclusively on history of networking and academic view of layering, and whatever I know about networking I learned after finishing my studies.
You Must Understand the Fundamentals to Be Successful
I was speaking with a participant of an SDN event in Zurich after the presentations, and he made an interesting comment: whenever he experienced serious troubleshooting problems in his career, it was due to lack of understanding of networking fundamentals.
Let me give you a few examples: Do you know how ARP works? What is proxy ARP? How does TCP offload work and why is it useful? What is an Ethernet collision and when would you see one? Why do we need MLD in IPv6 neighbor discovery?
Cisco IOS XE 'configure replace' Breaks on 'crypto pki' Commands
In February 2007, I published a (long gone) article describing the drawbacks of the Cisco IOS configure replace command. It was pretty bad at the time, but has improved significantly since. Alas, after 20 years, it still can’t cope with simple stuff that routers generate on their own.
I was reimplementing the netlab “reload configuration” functionality with Netmiko, and things seemed to work until I got random errors in the integration tests. Those tests are really trivial:
Worth Reading: LLM-Based Program Verification
I’m busy finalizing the 26.11 netlab release and don’t have the time or willpower for full-blown blog posts at the moment, so you’ll get more pointers than anything else.
I stumbled upon an interesting What’s going on with program verification? article, in which a researcher working on formal program verification (which is what we’ll badly need in the era of AI generating exploits at scale) describes the efforts to verify correctness with LLMs.
Worth Investigating (macOS): Kilobat
After I published a pointer to Octomon, Philip Seifi sent me a kind message pointing out his Kilobat tool (documentation). I haven’t tested it, but it seems like an interesting tool if you’re using your Mac in less-than-optimal environments (Philip seems to be a digital nomad, who would thus know too much about those).
If you’re already using the tool, I’d like to hear from you – please leave a comment.
Test Real-Life Routing Scenario with netlab
In his Labs as Code, Part 2: Real Images, Real Topology article, Tony Mattke described how he used netlab to recreate a customer routing scenario.
His article starts with the basics (importing an Arista cEOS container), and then slowly walks you through the process of building a netlab file that results in an 8-router network running BGP, BFD, OSPF, and a few routing policies. Absolutely marvelous reading if you’re new to netlab or exploring its capabilities.