Category: firewall

In the Deploying Zone-Based Firewalls book I wrote:

In early releases supporting zone-based policy firewall configuration (IOS 12.4(6)T), match protocol command cannot be used to classify traffic to or from the self zone. Only IP access lists can be used for traffic classification purposes.

Misha Volodko reported that the match protocol icmp command works for him when used with the self zone. Another small step toward perfect implementation :) ... and don't forget that you can always use class class-default to catch all the unclassified traffic (and log it before it's dropped, for example).

Euphrates Greene sent me a report of a very annoying “functionality” of Cisco 851/871: they're bridging between the inside (LAN) ethernet and outside (WAN) ethernet interfaces while they're running the ROMMON code (from the reload/power-up throughout the software decompression process until the control is transferred to the Cisco IOS). It's worth mentioning that these routers are commonly used as SOHO firewalls and that the internal LAN is exposed while the router is in the bridging mode.

Our security experts have replicated the behavior and reported it to Cisco PSIRT. Fortunately it's a known vulnerability, documented as CSCsd60259 (release note is available on CCO to registered users) and fixed with a ROMMON upgrade.

New routers are shipped with new ROMMON version, so you shouldn't be seeing this behavior on brand new boxes … but one cannot help but wonder why such a nasty behavior was not documented as a field notice/security advisory.

The information on the IOS XE software used by the recently launched ASR 1000 router is pretty scarce (there is still no link to the documentation available on CCO), but obviously some backdoor links already exist, as I was able to find some IOS XE-related documents with Google. One of the most amazing features I've found is the support for the security-oriented RFC 3514 which allows you to mark the security level of an IP packet.

The RFC 3514 requires the end host to participate in the process, but as most operating system vendors still don't have a trusted computing platform, a transparent proxy has to be implemented on the network edges to properly tag the ingress packets. ASR 1000 has the first high-speed implementation of the RFC 3514 proxy thanks to its non-deterministic parallel QuantumFlow processors.

The configuration of the RFC 3514 proxy is extremely simple: all you need to do is to configure auto-secure mark on the ingress interfaces of the ASR 1000. Once the security bit has been set, you can use the match ip security-bit 0|1 command in a class-map or a route-map on any router running IOS release 12.4(11)T or later (the command is still hidden).

A while ago a reader has asked me whether you could modify an IP access-list when the interface IP address changes. While that's definitely doable with Tcl and Embedded Event Manager, it's not a trivial task, so I've tried to understand why he would need such a functionality.

The answer was quite interesting: he's running NTP on his firewall router and thus needs to accept incoming NTP responses from an external NTP server. While that could be easily achieved with the following configuration (only the relevant bits-and-pieces are shown), he didn't want to make the access-list too generic (allowing NTP from the external server to any IP address).

ip inspect name DEFAULT100 tcp
ip inspect name DEFAULT100 udp
!
interface Dialer0
 description $FW_OUTSIDE$
 ip access-group 102 in
 ip inspect DEFAULT100 out
!
access-list 102 remark #### Dialer0 incoming ####
access-list 102 remark #### non-relevant lines deleted
access-list 102 permit udp host 1.2.3.4 eq ntp any eq ntp

This problem nicely illustrates a broader issues: the router does not inspect it's own traffic and thus does not prepare conduits for the return packets; you have to specify all the return traffic you're expecting in the incoming access list. This drawback has been fixed in IOS release 12.3(14)T with the introduction of the Inspection of Router-Generated Traffic feature. In our scenario you only need to change the inspect rules:

ip inspect name DEFAULT100 tcp router-traffic
ip inspect name DEFAULT100 udp router-traffic

... and the router synchronizes to an external NTP server:

sp#show ip inspect sessions
Established Sessions
 Session 474032B4 (192.168.1.3:123)=>(10.0.0.1:123) udp SIS_OPEN
sp#
01:04:34: %NTP-5-PEERSYNC: NTP synced to peer 10.0.0.1
01:04:34: %NTP-6-PEERREACH: Peer 10.0.0.1 is reachable

Note: This article is part of You've asked for it series.

One of my readers made an interesting observation when faced with configuring zone-based firewall on Cisco IOS: „My main issue is a confusion between when to use self and when to use in/outside.“

The rules are simple:

• Whenever you filter traffic transiting the router, you control it with a zone-pair specifying an inside and an ouside zone.
• The self zone controls traffic sent to the router itself or originated by the router.
• Unless you specify a zone-pair combining self zone with another zone, all traffic from that zone sent to the router itself is allowed (the router is not protected)
• To control traffic that the router can send into a zone use a zone-pair from self to another zone. Use inspect in the service-policy to allow the return traffic.
• To filter the traffic that the router can accept, use a zone-pair from another zone to self. Only the packets accepted by this zone-pair's service-policy will be accepted by the router.

More information about the self zone (as well as other aspects of zone-based firewall configuration) can be found in my digital book Deploying Zone-Based Firewalls published by Cisco Press.

In his latest Q&A post, Scott Morris mentioned an excellent Cisco article that describes routing tricks needed to implement sinkholes and remote blackholes in great details. Highly recommended reading.

I've got an interesting question a while ago: Do new Cisco routers still use CBAC?

Of course they do, it's just been renamed. The marketing department has decided that Context Based Access Control (CBAC) does not sound nearly so nice as the Cisco IOS Firewall. Even the command structure hasn't changed, you still use the ip inspect commands to configure it, unless, of course, you have IOS release 12.4(6)T or newer, where you can use zone-based policy firewall configuration.

This article is part of You've asked for it series.

Marko asked a very interesting question: What is the default class policy in a firewall policy-map (policy-map type inspect)? Or, using his original wording, "is it mandatory to use class class-default/drop" at the end of every policy map?

As it turns out, the default action for any class (unless you specify otherwise) is drop. By default, packets not matched by any traffic class are therefore dropped (unless you specify a different action in the class-default), similar to well-known ip access-list behavior.

In the security advisory detailing the Crafted IP Option Vulnerability (a nasty bug that allows an intruder to reset your router with a ping packet), the authors forgot to mention a great tool available in IOS release 12.3(4)T (and integrated in 12.4): the ability to filter packets with IP options in an access-list.

In my discussion of per-packet versus per-destination load sharing, I've relied on the "accepted wisdom" that out-of-order TCP packets reduce session performance (as a side note, out-of-order UDP packets are a true performance killer; just try running NFS with out-of-order packets).

Today I've discovered another huge show-stopper: stateful firewalls (read: almost everything in use today) might just drop out-of-order packets, resulting in TCP timeouts and retransmissions (and repeated timeouts will totally wreck the session throughput). Here's how Cisco devices handle this problem:

• PIX allows three out-of-order packets per TCP session (cannot be changed, but should be enough)


• You can configure out-of-order packet handling on ASA with the queue-lenght parameter of a tcp-map
.

• Cisco IOS firewall (formerly known as CBAC) drops out-of-order packets until release 12.4(11)T where you can use the ip inspect tcp reassembly configuration command (and it looks like the zone-based firewall configuration is not yet supported).

Cisco Press has just released my latest book (and my first digital one): Deploying Zone-Based Firewalls. The book covers a completely new way to configure IOS firewall feature set based on security zones you define on a router and inter-zone policies configured using the familiar class-maps and policy-maps.

You can preview this digital book (they call it Digital Short Cut) using the Safari technology at Cisco Press and buy it at Amazon.